Haart - Riesling Goldtröpfchen Kabinett 2011

David Schildknecht from Wine Advocate (R. Parker): 89 pnt

A Bernkastel-like suggestion of spiced cherries along with black tea and mint informs the Haart 2011 Piesporter Goldtropfchen Riesling Kabinett, hints of caramel and apple jelly adding to its expansive and soothing, if, to my mind, not especially Kabinett-like palate virtues. The finish here is less overtly sweet and more nuanced than in the corresponding Grafenberg, even though in terms of gross chemical analysis the wines are nearly identical, a reminder that imponderable factors (terroir anyone?) significantly influence a wine’s sense of sweetness. I would plan to enjoy this one by 2018.

Drink Date: 2013 - 2018

Theo and Johannes Haart began picking already on September 27 – several days earlier than they had even in 2003. As warm as the weather was in late September, they explained, dropping acidity and the potential for early botrytis – especially in the more water-retentive top sites of Piesport, but also in Wintrich in the aftermath of hail – left them no choice but to start early. “At first we picked nothing but healthy berries,” relates Johannes Haart, “but after three or four days there was botrytis; and three days after that we already had Trockenbeerenauslese.” That said, harvest continued all the way through October in order to optimize the potential of individual sites. But two notable features of this collection – the first analytically verifiable; the second an observation on my part – are that, surprisingly, its wines’ unusually low levels of acidity did not significantly increase under the influence of greater botrytization, and also, their flavor profiles have a lot in common and site-specificity strikes me as significantly less evident than usual. Kabinetts were fermented in stainless steel with watchful cooling because the Haarts were convinced that given the chemistry of their musts and elevated ambient temperatures, fermentations would otherwise have galloped. They bottled most of their 2011 collection in July, a bit later than usual because they believed the young wines definitely gained (and continue to gain after bottling) from aeration. Two different lots of Ohligsberg Trockenbeerenauslese and one of Goldtropfchen were still fermenting when I visited to taste the rest of the Haart’s 2011 collection.